11425733451. Nature and Scope of Comparative Politics.gkjha.pptx

Nature and Scope of
Comparative Politics
Gangesh Kr Jha
Assistant Prof.
Deptt. Of Political Science
Marwari College,Darbhanga

Comparative Government vs Comparative
Politics
• Though Comparative Government and Comparative
Politics are two different subjects, yet the modern
scientists have laid emphasis on the combined study of
both for obvious reason. Further, comparative method
has been used for the study of both .
• Aristotle, well known Greek Philosopher attempted for
the first time to understand the state, not so well
known idea in those days. He went on to study and
analyze almost 158 Constitutions to arrive at his
famous classification of “Government” into 6 broad
types depending upon the number and the purpose of
power beholden by the people.

Comparative Politics:Essence
• Comparative politics studies a broader range
of political activity, including government and
their institutions as well as other forms of
organizations not directly related national
government,e.g,tribes,communities,associatio
ns,unions.
• In other words it studies political as well as
non-political actors and their attendant
institutions.

Meaning of Comparative Politics
 Edward Freeman, “Comparative Politics is the
comparative analysis of the various forms of
governments and diverse political
institutions”.
 Michael Curtis, “Comparative Politics is
concerned with significant regularities,
similarities and differences in the working of
Political institutions and in political
behaviour.”

Growth of the Discipline
• Comparison with others has been a common habit in
humans. We compare many things with others to make
the right decision, and the history of this human trait is
as old as the existence of human civilization. The same
applies in the case of comparative politics.
• In the book named The Politics, written by Aristotle,
has the mention of comparative politics. In this book,
he compares “constitutions”, by introducing his famous
typology. Aristotle made a comparison of 158
countries, and that’s how comparative politics was
started.

Historical Growth
As civilization progresses and new changes in the
state system occured,Comparative Politics
underwent broadly five phases of
transformations to allow political scientists to
grasp phenomenon in more subtle ways:
 State and System Theories
 Cultural Theories
 Developmental Theories
 Class theories
 Political Economy Theories

Characteristics of Comparative Politics
• Descriptive Studies
• Historical-legalistic institutional studies
• Parochial
• Static
• Monographic

Approaches to Comparative Politics
Institutional-an approach to the study of politics and government that
focuses more on structure and dynamics of governing institutions
(comparison of formal instt.)
Structural- an approach to study of politics and government that empahasises
the relationships among groups and networks within larger system
cultural-an approach to the study of politics and government based on
understanding the influence of culture and cultural norms(how cultural
norms and practices support or undermine different political preferences
and forms)
Rational Choice-an approach to the study of politics and government based on
the idea that individuals work to maximize their benefits and minimize their
costs.(ability to model the essential political actions and make predictions).
Interpretative- an approach to the study of politics and government based
on the argument that politics is formed by the ideas we have about it

Nature of Comparative Politics
• Analytical and Empirical investigation
• Comparative study of the formal and informal
structures
• Study of infra-structures
• Emphasis on the study of Developing Societies
• Emphasis on the Inter-disciplinary method of
study
• Value-free study
• Quest of theory building
• Horizontal and vertical comparison

Scope of Comparative Politics
• All political structures-includes the study of all the
formal and informal, governmental, and extra-governmental
institutions and their structure;
• Functional-the knowledge of how all the formal and
informal institutes work within the country;
• Study of political behaviour- the study of voting
behavior, political participation, leadership recruitment, elite
behavior, mass politics, etc.;
• Study of similarity and differences-How two countries
are similar and how are they different from each other; and
• Study of all political systems-the political system of
any country defines its nature and the voting culture.

Scope of Comparative Politics: in
nutshell
1. Comparative study of Political systems
2.Study of constitutional systems
3.Study of Political culture
4. Study of political Socialization
5.Study of political Ideologies
6. Study of political Participation
7. Study of interest groups
8.Study of power, Influence and authority
9.Study of Political Elites, Political Violence and Political Corruption.
10. Study of Political Processes
11. Study of Problems of modernization and urbanization
12. Study of the role of the Bureaucracy
13. Study of the political Activities

Problems of Comparative Politics
Lack of common terminology ;
 Problems of fact-finding ;
Wide range of variables;
Gap between Constitutional Forms and Political
Realities ;
 Problem of inter-connection between values
behaviour;
 Fickle mindedness of Man;
Problem of defining of the boundaries;and
Universally acceptable results are not possible.

References
• Hague,Rod,Harrop,Martin & McCormick,
John(eds.),Comparative Government and
Politics,macmillan international,2019
• Chilcote,Ronald H,Theories of Comparative
Politics :The search for a paradigm
reconsidered,Westview Press,1994
• Eckstein,H &Apte D.C.,Comparative Politics;A
Reader

11425733451. Nature and Scope of Comparative Politics.gkjha.pptx

Related slideshows

More Related Content

What's hot

What's hot (20)

Similar to 11425733451. Nature and Scope of Comparative Politics.gkjha.pptx

Similar to 11425733451. Nature and Scope of Comparative Politics.gkjha.pptx (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

11425733451. Nature and Scope of Comparative Politics.gkjha.pptx